Order now
By Jane LaTour
Sisters in the Brotherhoods
Photo by Jon Bloom
Every purchase via this website supports human rights work.  Learn more.
Contact Us
What's Inside?
Praise for Sisters
As the lead named plaintiff in the class action lawsuit—Berkman v. Koch—that opened up the doors of the firehouses to
women, her career was constantly shadowed by the perceptions about her created in those early days. Throughout her 24
years in the department, Brenda Berkman was a “lighting rod” for all of the emotions that swirled around the subject of female
firefighters in New York City. As far along in her career as 1993, the Fire Department New York (FDNY) was still issuing
orders about Berkman: That no photos could be taken of her— either on or off duty—inside or outside of a firehouse.

After being promoted to lieutenant in 1995, her superior officer paid her a visit at Ladder 12. As she recalled, “The Captain
was not particularly happy to have me come there . . . A lot of it just had to do with reputation versus reality. The saying in the
Fire Department being: ‘Telephone, telegraph, tell a firefighter.’ There’s this very speedy and often inaccurate network of
rumors that get spread about people. Not just about me, but definitely about me . . . The main thing that has improved our
relationship is just getting to know one another. He realized that a lot of the rumors about me were inaccurate—that I’m a hard
worker; that I’m conscientious and I’m trying to do the best that I can—that I’m not looking to cause problems in the
firehouse; that I don’t have a thin skin. I have a good sense of humor. So these sorts of things allayed a lot of the initial
concerns he had about me coming there.”

In 2004, Berkman found it “hysterical”—her word for funny—that there were still men who wouldn’t take a seat next to her at
union meetings. Even then, Steve Cassidy, the head of the United Firefighters Association (UFA), the union that fought so hard
to keep the women out, couldn’t interact with her. “Every time I see [Steve] Cassidy, he won’t talk to me. He won’t look at
me,” she said. “As far as I know, he’s never met with the women firefighters’ organization [United Women Firefighters].”
In 1982, even before Probationary Firefighter Brenda
Berkman’s arrival at her first assignment, firefighters had
already formed opinions about her. “It was impossible for me
to keep a low profile,” she said. “Everybody knew my name.
I had been getting death threats. I had to get an unlisted
number . . . My picture had been in the paper. Everyone
knew that I was a lawyer. So that gave them another reason
to dislike me. They thought I was Jewish, so that was another
reason—another unacceptable group—plus I wasn’t from
New York.”
Brenda Berkman
Return to
"What's Inside?"